Constructing Investors’ Substantive Rights in International Investment Law

An Introduction

Authors

  • Param Bhalerao University of Vienna

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.25365/%20vlr-2026-10-2-160

Keywords:

international investment law, investment treaties, investors’ rights, direct rights, derivative rights, diplomatic protection, investor-State dispute settlement, investment arbitration, international legal personality, third-party beneficiaries, countermeasures, sunset clauses

Abstract

Classical international law treated States as its only subjects and individuals as mere objects, who could be affected by international law only through the acts of their States. Investment treaties added a significant dimension to the evolution of the individual’s status, by granting foreign investors the right to bring claims directly against host States before international arbitral tribunals. There has been no consensus, however, on the nature of the substantive rights that investors assert in such claims. Under the “derivative” model, investment treaties institutionalize diplomatic protection: the substantive rights remain with the home State, and the investor holds only a procedural right to enforce them. Under the “direct” model, the investor is a third-party beneficiary of the investment treaty and holds its own substantive rights under it. This paper offers an introductory overview of this debate. It traces the evolution of the individual from object to subject of international law and revisits the classical doctrine of diplomatic protection. It then shows that the choice between the two models has consequences for the operation of investment treaties. The paper suggests that investment arbitration cannot be understood merely as an institutionalized form of diplomatic protection, argues that the direct rights model offers the more coherent framework, and identifies questions for further research.

Author Biography

Param Bhalerao, University of Vienna

Param Bhalerao is an Ars Iuris uni:doc doctoral scholar at the Department of European, International and Comparative Law of the University of Vienna. He is writing his doctoral thesis on circumstances precluding wrongfulness in international investment law. He has practised as counsel and tribunal secretary in commercial and investment treaty arbitrations, and advised on international sanctions. He can be reached at param.bhalerao@univie.ac.at.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-18